Leading without the Script: How a First-Gen President Rewrites What Higher Ed Can Be
When Dr. Susan R. Burns left the suburbs of Topeka, Kansas, for college, she wasn't following a well-trodden family path. She was the third daughter in a tight-knit Midwestern family, but the first to leave home for higher education. “I had no idea what I was doing,” she says. “I was a good student … and I knew more school meant more money, so I was just trying to get through school fast.”
She decided to pursue clinical psychology at Emporia State University, and though it was only 60 miles away from home, landing on campus opened up a whole new world for Dr. Burns.
“My mind was expanded,” she says. “I grew up in the suburbs of Topeka. It was the first time I experienced diversity of all kinds.” The move wasn't just geographic. It would be the first in a series of transformative educational experiences, an early lesson in how education can shift the center of a person's world.
Her experience, though, was marked by excitement shadowed by uncertainty, ambition shaped by incomplete information, and the unsteady navigation of systems for which she had no frame of reference. “I was terribly advised,” she says. “I took all my major courses before general education. I just didn't know any better.”
After graduation, Burns didn't get into the Ph.D. programs in clinical psychology she initially hoped to pursue, so she enrolled in a master's program instead. It was there that she realized her calling wasn't clinical psychology, but academia.
“I was able to teach two sections of general psychology immediately,” she recalls. “I learned I loved teaching. I loved research.” She finished her master's degree and eventually earned a Ph.D. in personality psychology at Kansas State University.
It was there that a conversation between her advisor and a student broke her heart and helped her realize her place in higher education.
One of her students approached her and the senior faculty member asking for a letter of recommendation, and Burns told the student, “‘My letter would do you no good,’” she said. “I didn't know her well enough. And that was heart-wrenching to me.” She realized she needed to be somewhere smaller, somewhere she could see her students fully and be seen by them in return.
“I wanted to teach, I wanted to do research, and I wanted to be in a place where I could get to know my students,” she said.
That instinct—to know and be known—would become the cornerstone of her leadership.
Finding Her Way into Leadership
Burns describes her rise into academic leadership with a mixture of humility and disbelief. At Morningside College in Sioux City, Iowa, where she served as Associate Dean for Academic Affairs and was a tenured professor of psychology and statistics, “My provost saw more in me than I saw in myself,” she says. Female students gravitated toward her, asking her to advise them or take her courses. Her provost noticed the draw and gave her opportunities to mentor faculty and understand the inner workings of higher education administration. Those experiences widened the horizon of what she thought possible, even if nudged a bit by the president at the time.
“He came in on day one and said, ‘So what's your plan, kid?’” she remembers. “I said something like, ‘I think I want to be a provost someday.’ And he said, ‘No. You're going to be a college president one day. So what's your plan?’”
He invited her into the “behind-the-curtain” work of the presidency and mentored her on the ropes of higher education administration.
From there, she went on to serve as Vice President for Academic Affairs and Dean of Faculty at Clarke University in Dubuque, Iowa, where she worked under a president who was a national expert in accreditation. “I learned a lot about accreditation,” she notes—knowledge that would later serve her extraordinarily well.
Still, when the presidency at the College of Mount Saint Vincent opened, she almost didn't apply. “The very last day I could submit, I submitted my materials,” she says. “I told my husband, ‘This isn't going to work. They're not going to want this small-town person from Iowa.’” After an eight-month search, Dr. Susan Burns was named president of the College of Mount Saint Vincent in the Bronx, NY—she accepted the position without ever having stepped foot on campus.
Today, five years into her presidency, Burns says simply: “I couldn't imagine being anyplace else.”
A Leadership Philosophy Rooted in Seeing the Student
As president, Burns leads with a clarity shaped by her first-generation experiences. “Because I don't have the familial history with how higher education is supposed to be,” she says, “I am a firm believer in setting the traditional box aside. Higher education is terrible at saying, ‘I built it; you want it, right?’ I flip that. I ask, ‘What do you need, and how can we meet that need—with the understanding that there has to be a great education behind it?’”
In 2024, she successfully led the institution to new level of achievement: The College of Mount Saint Vincent became the University of Mount Saint Vincent, where more than half of undergraduates are Pell-eligible and more than half are first-generation, this philosophy translates into comprehensive support that is unusually human-centered. “We have this comprehensive experience that really meets learners where they are and treats them as people,” she says. Every student receives institutional aid. The university serves free breakfast and lunch. Students receive laptops. The campus culture emphasizes belonging, dignity, and the belief in a different future.
Her articulation of mission is both pragmatic and profoundly moral. “It's about belonging. It's about human dignity. It's about sharing in the possibility of a different life,” she says. “I say to anyone who will listen: if you've lost hope in our world, come spend time with our students.”
One of the strongest examples of this mission-driven adaptability is Mount Saint Vincent's partnership with an Orthodox Jewish women's seminary in Brooklyn. The university educates roughly 1,300 of these women, primarily online, in a way that honors cultural norms. Burns recognized early that the partnership needed deeper integration into the campus structure to truly support the students. “You are committed to the transformative effects of education, and you're committed to faith,” she told the seminary leaders. “You value the human.”
When asked about creating a culturally sensitive secondary nursing degree program, she faced a challenge. “The seminary said, ‘We cannot say that a nursing degree is culturally sensitive.’ And they were right. It's not just about the academic calendar.” She worked with the team to design a 14-month program that aligns with the Jewish holiday calendar, is taught by women, and keeps students together during clinical rotations. “This is what I mean when I say this institution is different,” she says. “We meet learners when, where, and how they need us.”
Leading through Crisis with Audacity and Hope
This moment in higher education is marked by political turmoil, declining enrollments, and increased scrutiny. Burns's institution is thriving—enrollment is growing, and the endowment is growing—but the external pressures are severe. “The decisions being made feel racist, they feel classist, they feel completely ignorant of what you need for a functioning economy,” she says.
When Title V funding cuts stripped the college of more than a million dollars—with no transition plan—she lost staff and had to scramble to fill the gap. The funding supported not only Hispanic students, but also equipment upgrades, student-faculty research, and opportunities that touched every corner of campus. “It was serving all of our students,” she says, frustration still evident.
“The decisions that are being made from my lens from what I'm seeing and how it impacts institutions like ours they feel racist, they feel classist, they feel completely ignorant to what you need for a functioning economy,” she adds.
Burns has become a frequent visitor to Washington, D.C., meeting with policymakers “across the aisle” because, as she tells lawmakers, “these students are your story. … These decisions will close colleges. This could close your alma mater.”
“It's been fascinating to me that those who agree to meet with me, they at their core still believe in higher education, but the attack on higher education is very real,” she says.
But she never loses sight of why she's in the work. Her audacity shows up everywhere—fundraising refocused on scholarships; the Mott Scholars program that provides housing and a $5,000 launch grant for students who persisted through homelessness or foster care; her insistence on designing programs around the specific needs of women whose lives have rarely been centered in higher education.
Through it all, she returns to the grounding force of her faith. “I've never felt that any challenge is insurmountable because I have hope,” she says. A cradle Catholic who once played piano at her campus chapel as a work-study job, Burns is clear about her complicated relationship with the church. “My faith is everything to me,” she says, “but it's not about needing to be this faith to be a successful leader. There are things I struggle with. I wrote a textbook on the psychology of sex and gender. I'm a huge advocate for LGBTQ+. I think the Church has a racist history. The Church is flawed because humans are flawed. What I love is that faith gives me something bigger than myself to believe in.”
Her cabinet includes leaders of varied and complicated faith backgrounds, yet every meeting begins with a prayer or silent reflection led by a different member. “It's just grounding,” she says. “It's a place for hope. A place to find comfort.”
The Audacity to Rewrite the Rules
Ask Burns what drives her, and she returns again and again to her students. “Their ‘yes’ to education is so inspiring,” she says. “They understand that their ‘yes’ is not just about them. It's about their family, their community, the generations that follow.”
She carries their stories with a fierce protectiveness. She is blunt about the stakes. “I am absolutely, unabashedly audacious when it comes to supporting my students,” she says. “I want to hear their story too.”