Don't Fear the “V”: Feminist Pedagogy as a Framework for Educational Leadership
The 2024 United States presidential election marked a jarring moment for many Americans, producing a profound sense of disorientation as social and political ground appeared to shift beneath their feet. In its aftermath, aspirations toward justice seemed dismissed in favor of behaviors and policies targeting race, gender, and ability—a swell of “leadership” practices modeling and endorsing undignified and inhumane ideologies. Among the many affected were women, whose rights, autonomy, and societal value were once again thrust into public contention and political vulnerability.
Within U.S. American schools, colleges, and universities, spaces that mirror and mold society, the repercussions were immediate and palpable, producing a somber collective mood. Though institutions of public education are called to political neutrality, the response was not merely about electoral results. Sadly, students, attuned observers of adult behavior, were witnessing the nation's highest model of leadership acting antithetically to the ideals espoused in most educational mission statements. These political shifts reverberated acutely for women, materialized in policy proposals, public rhetoric, and executive decisions signaling attempts to regulate bodies, dismiss expertise, and attempt to shrink civic participation. During a private, informal gathering with my administrative team on election morning, a colleague reflected on the electoral implications for gender equity and cultural discourse, offering a striking observation: “It's like our country is afraid of vaginas.”
Though provocatively phrased, this comment distills a central dilemma: how does one lead our nation's campuses when we fear the “V”? The same cultural anxiety that recoils from women's bodies as sources of vitality also recoils from public education as an engine of collective transformation. The vagina stands as a symbol of generativity: a capacity to create. Educational institutions share this power, generating possibility. To lead in education is to embrace this generative spirit, even while contending with the stark gap between distant governance and the lived realities of classrooms. Feminist pedagogy provides an orientation toward disrupting power structures, amplifying diverse voices, and naming how gendered dynamics shape the very fabric of schooling. Feminist pedagogy also calls educational leaders—women and men alike—into action by urging them to take courageous, reflective risks; confront entrenched hierarchies; and model ethical, care-centered leadership (Pugliese, 2023; Fuller, 2022). This pedagogy offers a bold and timely response, emerging not only as a viable instructional philosophy but as a leadership framework centered in equity.
Framing leadership through feminist pedagogy equips educational leaders with tools for inclusive, justice-oriented practice. Chaaban et al.'s (2025) study reinforces core feminist leadership practices by highlighting how leaders who foreground identity, relational care and equity-driven decision-making are best positioned to disrupt systemic marginalization and advance more just school environments. Drawing from these tenets and the generative spirit of the “V,” leadership entry points grounded in feminist pedagogy, symbolically representing its vitality, form a leadership model rooted in feminist values, designed to disrupt oppressive systems and reimagine educational contexts as more inclusive: spaces that will not fear the “V.” Applied to higher education models, the core principles of feminist pedagogy become strategies for transformation: Collaborative decision-making flattens hierarchical barriers, care-based leadership models relational accountability, reflective practice cultivates critical consciousness among faculty, and empowering voice and agency ensures all members of the learning community can participate in shaping its future (Crabtree, Sapp, & Licona, 2009).
Rationale: Reimagining Power, Equity, and Voice in Educational Leadership
Feminist thought equips leadership teams to examine not only pedagogy, but the cultural and structural forces embedded in educational spaces: spaces where gender, power, and identity are constructed and contested. Classrooms reproduce cultural norms and expectations, both overtly and subtly (McGregor, 2003; Martino & Cumming-Potvin, 2018). Educational spaces are fertile, and, much like the “V,” serve as sites of creation shaped both by those who fear its power and those willing to embrace it.
Feminist pedagogies epitomize Freire's (1970) vision of education as a practice of freedom, a sense of liberation highly aligned with the female quest for bodily autonomy. As Elwell and Buchanan (2021) note, Freire did not fear the “V”; he embraced the generative and creative potential of education. Feminist pedagogy extends this vision, calling on public education to be a tool for systemic change. Applied to leadership practices, feminist pedagogy reframes power as relational rather than hierarchical and extractive (Webb, Allen, & Walker, 2002). In practice, leaders co-design policies with faculty and students, cultivating spaces where voices historically marginalized are amplified and make decisions that invest in long-term growth rather than short-term compliance. Under this practice, classrooms become sites of collective problem-solving, mentorship, and co-created learning, while campus-wide initiatives prioritize equity and community well-being over rigid mandates. Feminist pedagogy invites educational leaders to approach the “V”—the generative and sometimes intimidating spaces of leadership—, with courage, curiosity, and a willingness to be transformed, knowing when leadership and schooling are grounded in relational and regenerative power, public education itself becomes an engine for social transformation.
Embracing the “V” Through Feminist-Informed Leadership
The application of feminist pedagogy to higher education leadership is best articulated through four interconnected entry point practices that incubate transformative experiences. Together, these practices translate the ethos of feminist pedagogy into systems-level action.
Entry point: Promotion of collaborative decision-making
Feminist pedagogy emphasizes the co-construction of knowledge and the redistribution of power (Light, Nicholas, & Bondy, 2015). Leaders who center collaboration regularly invite instructors, staff, students, and community members to co-create the rules, programs, and initiatives that define their learning spaces, making co-creation a semesterly practice across departments. Engaging multiple voices mirrors the courage and openness required to enter the “V,” acknowledging both the creativity and the vulnerability inherent in collaborative work.
Incubation: An administrator establishes a site-based leadership team consisting of faculty, students, and community stakeholders who contribute thinking toward key decisions about curriculum, disciplinary policies, and resource allocation. To make this team functional, regular meetings are scheduled with clear agendas, data and contextual background for topics are made transparent, and structured discussions are facilitated to ensure all voices are heard. Team members propose initiatives and dissect thinking, allowing ideas to be tested collaboratively. By decentralizing authority, the administrator cultivates a fertile environment for diverse perspectives, reinforces collective ownership of outcomes, and models the courage needed to navigate challenging, life-giving spaces.
Entry point: Model care-based leadership
Feminist pedagogy emphasizes relational, care-centered approaches, positioning empathy, emotional well-being, and holistic development at the heart of educational practice (Noddings, 2013). Leaders who model care-based leadership breed life-giving spaces, like the “V,” while embracing vulnerability and connection as sources which cultivate trust within learning communities.
Incubation: A Dean promotes a wellness-centered work culture by modeling responsiveness to the emotional realities of students and staff. By normalizing mental health days, integrating trauma-informed practices into existing professional development, and fostering reflection and emotional learning as core course competencies, leaders signal that care is a core expectation rather than an add-on. These approaches can be implemented through cost-conscious strategies such as allowing staff and faculty to access sick days for mental health purposes, leveraging training initiatives, and adjusting existing schedules to demonstrate that wellness-centered leadership is grounded in intentional practices and values. This ethic of care is woven into daily structures and decision-making which humanizes teaching and learning while reinforcing an educational culture that is relational and supportive.
Entry point: Encourage reflective practice
Feminist pedagogy values reflexivity and self-awareness, fostering spaces where individuals examine assumptions, biases, and the impact of their actions (Shrewsbury, 1987). Leaders who cultivate reflective practice guide educators into the challenging spaces of the “V,” embracing discomfort and curiosity as opportunities for growth and transformation.
Incubation: A department chairperson establishes a reflective teaching cohort in which faculty engage in collaborative inquiry regarding inclusion. Through journaling, observations, and dialogue, teaching staff maintain responsiveness to student needs. In this model, reflection is not an afterthought, but a habitual stance that challenges defensiveness, nurtures insight, and reinforces the courage required to engage in life-giving work.
Entry point: Empower voice and agency
Feminist pedagogy centers marginalized voices, fosters self-advocacy, and positions learners as active participants in knowledge creation. Leaders who cultivate agency guide students and staff into the generative, courageous spaces of the “V” where speaking, questioning, and co-creating are not feared, but embraced as essential acts of growth and transformation (Freire, 1970).
Incubation: A university honors program implements student-led advising meetings, where learners present evidence of their growth, setting personal goals and reflecting on challenges. To complement this work, faculty collaborate to design curricula reflecting students' lived experiences. They may elect to incorporate local community issues into research projects or select literature mirroring cultural identities in the classroom. These practices embody feminist pedagogy in action: They foster the courage to speak, the freedom to question, and the invitation to co-create knowledge and learning environments. Much like the “V” itself, a site of vitality, these practices transform education from something delivered into something co-created, signaling that our universities and colleges are most alive when they cultivate spaces of shared agency.
The “V” Reclaimed
In examining leadership practices, feminist pedagogy offers a compelling path forward, fostering transformative leadership. This framework resists hierarchy, empowers agency, and is deeply grounded in social responsibility. It transcends the question of whether women or men occupy positions of authority and instead centers the responsibility of educational leaders to cultivate environments where diverse perspectives intentionally shape educational practice.
Imagine this tangible philosophy in the daily practices of education: site-based leadership teams redistributing authority, wellness-centered approaches that humanize teaching and learning, teaching cohorts prioritizing reflective practice, and student-led advising shifting evaluation into ownership. Each strategy reflects the radical energy of the ‘V,’ insisting leadership is not about compliance, but about creation and collective transformation.
This framing offers not merely a possibility, but a necessity for our female leaders—for all leaders! In the wake of a political moment modeling a regressive, exclusionary form of leadership, feminist pedagogy reasserts public education as a place where dignity and equity are not negotiable. In this era, where policies and rhetoric increasingly threaten inclusive spaces, the need for leaders who courageously embrace relational power and reflection has never been more urgent. Educational spaces become sites of renewal when leaders refuse to shrink from complexity and controversy. While such leadership may be met with resistance from some stakeholders, it can be reasonably addressed through transparency, dialogue, and the consistent modeling of care and ethical responsibility, and leaders can gradually build trust and legitimacy even in a polarized environment.
In this inviting context, the final provocative quandary remains: The challenge is not to fear the vagina, but to reclaim it, metaphorically, as a voice of school leadership.
Dr. Sonja Gedde is a visionary educator, school administrator, and affiliate professor, blending data-driven insight with bold, practical innovation to curate learning environments where students and faculty thrive. With experience across K–graduate education, her research examines identity, pedagogy, and leadership in critical educational contexts. She speaks internationally, has delivered a TEDx Talk, and shares her work on Instagram: @theprincipledoffice.
References
- Chaaban, Y., Badwan, K., & Arar, K. (2025). Educational leadership for social justice: A systematic review of empirical evidence. Review of Education, 13(2), e70077. https://doi.org/10.1002/rev3.70077. PubMedWeb of Science®Google Scholar
- Crabtree, R. D., Sapp, D. A., & Licona, A. C. (Eds.). (2009). Feminist pedagogy: Looking back to move forward. Johns Hopkins University Press. Google Scholar
- Elwell, A., & Buchanan, R. (2021). Feminist pedagogies in a time of backlash. Gender & Education, 33(2), 156–170. Web of Science®Google Scholar
- Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Continuum.
- Fuller, K. (2022). Feminist perspectives on contemporary educational leadership. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003253341.
- Light, D., Nicholas, L., & Bondy, E. (2015). Feminist pedagogy: Theory, practice, and activism. Canadian Journal of Education Administration and Policy, 2015(1), 1–26. Available at: bit.ly/4ing9fK.
- Martino, W., & Cumming-Potvin, W. (2018). Gender, schooling, and the construction of gendered identities: A complex web of values, norms, and power relationships. Gender and Education, 30(3), 309-324. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540253.2018.1432156. Google Scholar
- McGregor, H. (2003). Gendered spaces of schools. Gender and Education, 15(3), 211–224. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540250303673. Google Scholar
- Noddings, N. (2013). Caring: A relational approach to ethics and moral education ( 2nd ed.). University of California Press. Google Scholar
- Pugliese, N. (2023). Feminist pedagogies. In Gender Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Academia (pp. 204–212). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003363590-22. Google Scholar
- Shrewsbury, C. M. (1987). What is feminist pedagogy? Women's Studies Quarterly, 15(3/4), 6–14. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40003511.
- Webb, L. M., Allen, M. W., & Walker, K. L. (2002). Feminist pedagogy: Identifying basic principles. Academic Exchange Quarterly, 6(1), 67–72.