Women, Knowledge, and ‘the Wicked’—Deserving a Chance to Fly
During the holidays, I saw the film “Wicked: Part I,” which tells the story of Elphaba Thropp, the misunderstood Wicked Witch of the West of “The Wizard of Oz.” This movie depicts Elphaba essentially as a young woman learning about her potential. First, she cannot control her powers; people treat her as strange and isolate her. But at the moving end of the film, Elphaba, finally in charge of her forces and letting them loose, flies on her broom, singing that everyone deserves a chance to fly, and nobody will bring her down. Walking out of the cinema, I noticed the audience was mostly female. Many women seemed moved and had teared up. Even if these women didn’t identify as witches, Elphaba’s story has struck a chord with so many—what it feels like to be different, what it feels like to be ostracized or discounted for what should be considered a gift.
On the same week, I had the opportunity to elaborate the experience of difference further. I was invited to lead a workshop on women and magic in a professional women’s club. The members of this Brussels-based club are well-educated, and they come from all over the world and represent all age groups. The purpose of the workshop was to offer the members a survey of women as witches throughout history. Before the event, the organizers told me that there was a lot of interest in the workshop, but I could not have imagined how engaged people participating in the event were. All participants—including, for instance, businesswomen, NGO workers, consultants, and artists—were familiar with the negative stereotype that a woman who is somehow knowledgeable is often seen as suspicious, manipulative, greedy, or perhaps cold.
In other words, she is a witch.
Many participants shared their personal stories about how their experiences differed from those of the men they knew. Some mentioned their encounters with esoteric knowledge. This could mean a special relationship with nature, including knowledge of how to use some plants. It could mean finding energy in women-exclusive spaces. It could also mean practicing mindfulness, meditation, or rituals, and paying attention to their menstrual cycles. During the workshop, we also discussed various forms of lucky charms, how using your favorite jewelry may bring you confidence and “power-clothes”—you know, the outfit that makes you feel powerful (maybe even “magical”!). I realized that these were practices we were implementing to call forth and embrace our powers.
This topic also speaks to women in higher education in different ways. On the one hand, we are familiar with biases, as women were not welcome in academic settings for a long time. Therefore, women’s experiences and trajectories to knowledge production have been marginalized, and still today, when they are compared to those of men, they frequently appear as “different.” This distinction is unhelpful and leads to “othering” women’s experiences. However, similar to the women of the workshop, I am sure that many of us have created our own strategies to feel powerful. Those may vary from the use of power-clothes to a calming walk before an energy draining meeting.
One important strategy that the film “Wicked: Part I” reminds us about is the support of others. A defining moment in the movie is when Glinda begins to see Elphaba and the two become friends. Friendship has its complications but having someone to really see, accept, and support her truly quickly shifts Elphaba’s perspective. Seeing herself through Glinda’s eyes makes her start to appreciate herself more.
This part of the story is a helpful reminder about the significance of mentors, peer mentors, and thoughtful colleagues. The professional organization of which I am a member gives awards to women mentors every year. After the nominations are announced, those who nominated their mentors read the statements of support they wrote. These letters are often very touching. Whereas they may speak about concrete ways the mentors supported their academic careers, they also regularly speak about mentors as people who recognize their mentees’ potential. Their trust and approval were all it took to make the mentee thrive. Whereas the word “witch” is not mentioned, the mentor’s presence was like magic to the mentee: it changed everything. Moreover, a professional women’s organization can be compared to a coven. Such organizations support women by frequently questioning and challenging the rules of patriarchy and by setting their own rules.
While many women still struggle to be recognized for their abilities fully, I acknowledge these concerns, especially women of different minority groups, such as people with disabilities, LGBTQ+ folks, and racialized and Indigenous women. Amid these challenges, women can find inspiration in characters whose knowledge and capabilities have been questioned. A witch is an important symbol of resistance because she is a figure who does not seek to please everyone but remains truthful in their own vision. Hence, she can inspire women to think about what we need to be authentic. Not everybody wants to be a witch, but everyone wants to be appreciated for who they are and have a chance to fly.
Hanna Tervanotko is an associate professor of religious studies at McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario.