The Myth of Balance: Leading Well in a Season of Overcommitment
We love to talk about “work–life balance” as though it’s a natural state you just…arrive at, as if once you hit the right combination of early-morning yoga and Sunday meal prep, the scales will even out and stay there.
Here’s the truth: Balance is not a constant. It’s not even always possible, especially for women leaders in higher education running complex portfolios, managing people and politics and still showing up for your families, your communities, and yourselves.
Some seasons, “balance” looks more like “strategic imbalance.” And that’s not failure—that’s leadership.
Why the idea of perfect balance sets us up to fail
The traditional image of balance assumes we can give equal time, energy and focus to every area of life, every single day. That’s just not real life. Crises don’t schedule themselves; kids get sick, parents need care and unexpected opportunities don’t ask us when it’s convenient for them to drop into our inboxes.
When we chase a fixed idea of balance, we set ourselves up for constant guilt. If you’re at work, you feel as though you should be home. If you’re home, you feel as though you should be working. You’re never fully present anywhere.
So instead of balance, I focus on alignment—making sure your time and energy are going where they matter most in this season.
Step 1: Identify your current season
Not all seasons are the same. Some are growth seasons, some are grind seasons, and some are recovery seasons. Each demands a different distribution of your energy.
Ask yourself:
- What are the top three priorities in my life right now?
- Which of these are time-sensitive, and which can wait?
- What will I need to say “no” to in order to focus here?
When you know the season you’re in, you can stop judging yourself by the standards of a different season. If you’re in a grind season—launching a new program, going through accreditation, caring for a newborn—give yourself permission to lean in hard there and adjust other commitments accordingly.
Step 2: Choose your “yes” with intention
One of the fastest ways to lose alignment is to say “yes” to everything that comes your way. In higher ed, this is especially tempting—every committee feels important, every student story pulls on your heart and every request for your expertise seems urgent.
But if you’re saying “yes· to everything, you’re actually saying “no” to something else—often the things that matter most.
Before committing, ask:
- Does this align with my priorities for this season?
- Am I the only person who can do this, or can I delegate/share it?
- Will saying “yes” to this require me to say “no” to something more important?
Step 3: Build guardrails, not walls
I don’t believe in rigid boundaries that make you untouchable—leadership requires availability. But I do believe in guardrails: intentional limits that protect your time, focus and well-being without cutting you off from the work or people you care about.
Examples:
- Setting one “meeting-free” afternoon each week for deep work or catch-up.
- Keeping one weeknight completely free of work events.
- Blocking personal appointments on your work calendar so they don’t get swallowed.
Guardrails keep you from careening into burnout.
Step 4: Make peace with the trade-offs
Every “yes” has a cost. If you accept a national speaking engagement, you might miss a family dinner or two. If you prioritize a student retention initiative this semester, your personal research project might move slower.
Instead of fighting this reality, own it. Say to yourself—and sometimes out loud—“I’m choosing this right now, and I’m okay with what that means I’m not choosing.”
This mindset turns trade-offs from a source of guilt into a source of clarity.
Step 5: Schedule joy as though it’s a meeting
This isn’t fluff—it’s maintenance. When you’re in a season of overcommitment, joy is fuel. And if you don’t put it on the calendar, it will get crowded out.
Think about:
- A standing lunch date with a friend who energizes you.
- A short daily ritual—coffee in silence before the day starts, a midday walk or a playlist that makes you dance in your chair.
- Quarterly getaways, even if they’re just 24 hours away from home.
These are not “extras”—they are part of the work of sustaining yourself as a leader.
Step 6: Reassess often
Your season will change—sometimes faster than you expect. A project will wrap, a crisis will calm or a personal situation will shift. The priorities you set in January may not fit by April.
Build in regular checkpoints—monthly or quarterly—to ask:
- What’s working in how I’m spending my time?
- What’s draining me that I can change or drop?
- Has my season shifted, and do my commitments need to shift with it?
The freedom in letting go of “perfect”
When you stop chasing a mythical version of balance, you free yourself to lead and live with more intention. You get to decide what matters right now—and unapologetically arrange your time and energy to match.
Some seasons will still feel overwhelming. But when you’re aligned, even an overcommitted season can feel purposeful instead of chaotic. And that difference? That’s what keeps good leaders from burning out before they’ve done their best work.