Telephobia in Higher Education Admissions

I recently started a job at a graduate school in Portland, Oregon. I've switched higher ed departments and transitioned from academic advising over to admissions. I am learning a lot about communication because my job focuses largely on student outreach.

Our Vice President of Admissions recently went to a continuing education conference that focused on students' communication preferences. The pie chart that he shared with us upon his return listed students' preferred methods of outreach. There were only three methods on the chart: text, email, and chatbot. He asked us all to recognize what was missing: phone calls.

When I started the job, I was taken aback to hear that I was required to reach out to a prospective student 11 times before closing their file as “not interested.” I became even more nervous when I learned that over half of those attempts should be phone calls.

It didn't take long to notice some patterns. First, I would guess that around 80–90% of my outgoing phone calls were unanswered and went to voicemail. Second, emails got a much better response, but still only around a 50% response rate. Third, text messages had the highest response rate. I also noticed the length of the message matters, whether text or email. The shorter the message, the more likely it was to get a response from the student.

Another pattern I noticed related to gender and age of the student. For whatever reason, it seems like when I have an inquiry who is listed as male, they usually answer the phone. The percentage of women who answer the phone is much lower than men.

Age also shows a pattern in the phone call statistics. The age gap in the prospective students I talk to is quite large. The youngest of the group are in their early 20s and range all the way into the late 60s. It seems the younger students rarely answer while the older students usually answer.

After us counselors are more than halfway through our 11 attempts, we start offering an option to close their inquiry if they're no longer interested. My boss shared with me that she gets more close requests by acting like a bot. I tried this out for myself, and she was right. A message that has a long explanation that a student is welcome to have us close their inquiry is less likely to get a response than a short text that reads, “Still interested in UWS? If not, reply C to close inquiry.”

When considering why students are more likely to respond to a bot text rather than an email from a human admissions counselor, we found a few reasons. First, it seems like when students respond to us after a human-sounding email, they always feel like they have to provide a reason for not being interested. “It's just not the right time,” “It's just too much money,” and “I'm not interested anymore.” When answering what students think is a bot, no explanation is needed.

We also realized that sending one character via text to close their inquiry rather than a long, detailed message is an absolute timesaver. It's convenient and can be done from their phone with a few taps.

When researching for this article, I bumped into the mention of a condition called “telephobia.” It basically means having a fear of making or receiving professional phone calls. A troubling part of the increase in texting and chatbots is that telephobia seems to be increasing in young people.

Although the initial communication to students tends to be an email or text, as the student moves along the admissions process to being accepted and enrolled, the phone becomes a more common way to touch base. We've found this is because so much info is often needed, it's a lot more practical to get that information in a short phone call rather than ping-ponging back and forth with emails.

With the new knowledge our admissions department learned from the recent conference, we've been instructed to rely a little less on phone calls and a little more on text for prospective student outreach. I'm already noticing a ton more interaction and the contact we've made has been much more fruitful because we're getting bits of information rather than a student's voicemail.

Although it's sad to see phone calls be “phased out,” I think we're doing the right thing by getting with the times and reaching out to students in a way that's more likely to connect with them. I'm optimistic that we'll be building more relationships with prospective students as we adapt to these new communication norms.

Stephanie McCoy is an academic advisor from Portland, Oregon. Stephanie has a master's degree in education with a focus in educational leadership. She is a freelance writer who loves to write about the importance of equity in education. She enjoys reading, travel, and living life with her beloved husband, two kids, and puppy named Waffles.

Back to listing