Facilitators Help Middle School Girls Build Confidence and Sisterhood Through Theatre
On a balmy Monday afternoon in June on Webster Avenue, Trisha Jeffrey, a teaching artist for the theatre education non-profit International Girls Ensemble (IGE), tapes a giant yellow sheet of paper to a bookshelf titled “Girls Circle Play,” listing possible themes in colorful marker: “Going through changes. Growing pains,” “Betrayal,” “A girl discovers she's turning into a butterfly.” Jeffrey leads the group of students through a mindful warm-up before rehearsing a scene they will perform next week at their final meeting. She instructs them to inhale through the nose and exhale through the mouth. “You all are amazing, creative, talented, intelligent, powerful, strong, phenomenal young women,” she tells the room of 12 girls. “So take that in. Let that be part of your breath.”
Girls Circle was born from the school's social worker Michelle Jervis's observation that in the hallways and classrooms of the school “a lot of our conflicts were among our young ladies.” With assistance from the school's principal and others, she proposed the after-school program to reflect a sorority sisterhood—a circle without any hierarchy. Jervis's congruous partnership with IGE, co-founded by Jacqueline Raymond Wegman and Amanda McDowall—whose mission is to empower girls through theatre and arts education—began in 2018 after McDowall led a workshop at the middle school.
Studies show girls' self-confidence declines by 30% between the ages of eight and 14 (for more information, please visit bit.ly/40y9KqM). According to Sociologist Dr. Katherine S. van Wormer, when sharing the same classroom as high-achieving boys, girls are less confident and “apt to set their educational goals lower,” often experiencing less interaction with their teachers by 10 to 30%. However, in a classroom with other high-achieving girls, they are “more likely to pursue ambitious educational goals even when of average ability themselves.”
Girls Circle consists mainly of seventh graders who are 12 and 13 years old. McDowall, who has an MA in Arts Administration, says teaching improvisation, where performers make up lines on the spot, has become a valuable tool outside the classroom. Students are encouraged to take a breath to self-regulate “and say ‘yes,’” says McDowall. This refers to the principle in improv performing of “yes, and—”, where performers accept their scene partner's truth and help expand on their new ideas.
“It's kind of a never-ending cycle when you, ‘Yes, and—.’ You can build on each idea and build on the relationships and say, ‘Yes, what you're saying is really wonderful.’” says Jeffrey, an actor and singer raised in the Bronx. She wishes programs like IGE existed when she came of age, having listened to conversations Jervis leads with girls about being a woman, the pressures of social media, meeting grades, and doing right by their parents. “Oftentimes as women, we're told what we can't do,” she says, “and here I am telling them, ‘No, you can do what you want.’”
“I think the most important thing is getting buy-in, and buy-in always comes from them being able to shape how the conversation goes and where it goes,” Jervis says. McDowall agrees, emphasizing the importance of having a safe space for conversations the girls may not be able to have at home.
IGE and the Girls' Circle program is not focused on grades; instead, it emphasizes building trust and sharing ideas. This approach allows for “growth and development” so the girls can “have agency over themselves,” says Jeffrey, who was drawn to IGE's mission of teaching leadership skills. “That's why I like working with IGE, because the goal of International Girls Ensemble is to enlighten and empower young women, and I don't think enough programs do that.”
Theatre Offers an Outlet, Newfound Internal ResourcesThe sometimes-painful realities students at middle school (MS) 391 have faced in recent years make girlhood even more precarious. Of the New York City boroughs, the Bronx was hit hardest during COVID-19 (according to a report from the State Comptroller, which you can read at bit.ly/4aialul), with students at the middle school losing family members and “having panic attacks in the classrooms, just feeling unsafe and anxious,” says Jervis. I spoke with her and McDowall in the “calming room” outfitted with chromatic liquid floor tiles, shelves of spiky tactile balls and sensory fidget tubes, and a mini waterfall fountain. “We also had some, you know, civil unrest,” she says, referring to violence on Fordham Road and Webster Avenue, most notably, the brutal gang killing of Lesandro “Junior” Guzman-Feliz outside a Bronx deli and the 2022 fire in a high-rise near the school that took the lives of 19, including one student at MS 391. The space has become a refuge for Girls Circle and other students and a “healing room for teachers.”
For IGE teaching artist Natalie Peguero, who attended MS 391 and grew up across the street, choir class was her calming room. Peguero, a promising student with a penchant for singing in the cafeteria, resisted falling into the wrong crowd, with many friends turning to gangs. She met a choir teacher who “saved my life” by allowing her to join a choir class for bilingual students learning English through music. Peguero, who is bilingual, already spoke English but was admitted to the class because she was eager to pursue singing and songwriting. “Music saved my life. The arts saved my life, but I was also motivated by it.”
Like Peguero, Jeffrey says that theatre saved her life. She describes herself as studious and curious, which was frowned upon. “It's almost like I had to hide myself, so there was a level of shame.” Some of Jeffrey's peers dropped out of school or ended up incarcerated, but her introduction to the performing arts “opened my entire world so that I could see past the four-block radius of the Bronx of where I grew up.”
Teaching artists from the same area as MS 391 allows students to resonate with Peguero and Jeffrey. “I show up as myself,” Peguero says, adding that students are often surprised she attended the same school. “I always make it a point to not just talk about the acting, but how this serves you in society. You have to show up. You have to be able to speak up, to communicate, to collaborate.”
However, there was some trepidation, as theatre was new territory for the girls. In the beginning, Jeffrey says some students were “really shy and often withdrawn, sometimes apologetic” and “a lot of them were critical of themselves and each other, but also critical of me.” She credits Jervis with creating a gateway for her to do what she needs with IGE. Because Jervis has built trust with the girls, she's created an environment where they feel safe expressing their thoughts without judgment.
“I've learned to be more confident and express myself more,” Bintou, a seventh grader, says of Girls Circle and IGE. “Last year, I wasn't really into theatre, but Ms. Trisha really inspired me.” Hailey, also a seventh grader, agrees: “I like how we can share our stories without feeling judged.” She says of theatre: “It kind of … opens up your shell.”
All-Female Theatre Company Born out of Undergrad ExperienceRaymond Wegman and McDowall met while studying theatre at the University at Buffalo, NY, where both graduated with their Bachelor of Fine Art (BFA). They consequently formed a female production company called the Radium Girls in 2013. “It's kind of amazing looking back, you know, putting on theatre in the East Village,” says Raymond Wegman. “But it was female playwrights that highlighted strong female characters because we were sick of seeing the tropes of men.”
The origin story of IGE began with a 2016 trip to Northwest Thailand, where Raymond Wegman and McDowall volunteered alongside friends to teach at a migrant center in Myanmar for refugees. Raymond Wegman called it “life changing.” The impact of their work became clear when the girls in Myanmar shared that they'd taken the theatre skills they'd learned from them back to their villages to teach others. “That gave me chills.”
Raymond Wegman explains that seeing the bonds and sisterhood of the women empowered by theatre and giving back to their communities was their inspiration for creating IGE's Female Ambassador Program. Their global female ambassadors have extended beyond Thailand to include women in Kenya, South Sudan, and Cambodia, where they continue to support and employ future teachers and theatre makers. “Learning the craft is great, but that's not what the work is,” says McDowall. “The work is using the theatre as the vehicle for whatever it is that that community needs.”
In 2018, they officially launched a 501c3, which became IGE, and today serve schools in Manhattan, Harlem, Queens, and the Bronx. McDowall and Raymond Wegman applied for a grant to work at MS 391 through the Huiying Memorial Foundation for Women's Health and Wellness. “We applied with that lens being we want to use theater to battle mental health issues that are impacting young girls specifically in that middle school age,” says McDowall, who says the foundation liked IGE's mission to use the arts as a mechanism for expression, healing, self-regulation, and having difficult conversations.
Jervis was brought into IGE to help develop the curriculum, enabling teaching artists to be more considerate of the girls and their needs. “We feel really grateful to have her in our corner and to support her and the work she's already doing on the ground,” says McDowall.
Back in the classroom, Jeffrey runs rehearsals for the “Spill the Tea” podcast, a modern amalgamation of the TV shows Maury and The Wendy Williams Show, where two girls in marker-mustached faces called Tyrone and Michael tussle over a girl named Tasha.
After a student recommends one of the characters sit down to show restraint mid-argument, Jeffrey, also a Broadway performer, ardently agrees—”Great point”—giving the student playing the character a new direction with the idea that, “I'm going to sit down before I hurt somebody.”
Not only is theatre helping empower young girls to feel more confident, but the arts can serve as a pathway toward higher education. According to research supported by the National Endowment for the Arts, arts students are 29% more likely to pursue a postsecondary education than non-arts students.
“I feel like theatre is definitely the pathway to academic success,” says Jeffrey, who earned her BA in Theatre from Lehman College NY. “It was for me, and I see it happening with other young people that I work with through IGE and through other programs.”
“As a kid, I was lost in math class,” remembers Raymond Wegman, and she “would often fail tests.” She remembers a high school math teacher telling her she might qualify for community college: “I felt like I wasn't smart.” But her school offered choir and theatre, “which was really lucky for me. I excelled at these. I stood out. Music and theatre boosted my self-esteem, gave me a purpose, and was the reason I applied to college as a first-generation college student.” Once she learned she could major in theatre, she decided to pursue higher education and now has a master's degree in Educational Theatre from the City College of New York.
Maria Prudente is a writer and journalist. Her work has appeared in the LA Times, The Daily Beast, Chicago Tribune, and others. She lives in the Washington, D.C. area.