Beyond Equality: Responsive Agency and the Responsibility of Women Leaders in Higher Ed

Higher education has never been a neutral playing field. It wasn't built for women, and despite decades of effort, it still doesn't quite know what to do with women. Enter Savanah N. Landerholm's Beyond Equality: Women Leaders in Higher Education (published November 2024 by Fortress Press) which argues—rightly—that equality is a necessary but insufficient goal. Equality suggests that if we can just get the numbers right, if we can place women in the right leadership roles, the work is done. But what happens when the structures remain the same? When the culture continues to demand assimilation rather than transformation?

Landerholm's concept of responsive agency is the call to action we've been waiting for, but it's also the accountability check that many women leaders in higher ed have avoided. Responsive agency demands that we do more than survive institutions that weren't designed for us. It insists that we engage with them critically, challenge them strategically, and reshape them intentionally.

The Insanity of Equality

We've spent years chasing seat counts, watching the percentages of women in leadership roles inch up like some victory metric. But representation alone isn't revolution. If women in leadership are forced to play by the same restrictive rules, abide by the same dysfunctional norms, and adopt the same leadership styles that have historically excluded us, then what, exactly, have we won?

Landerholm outlines three archetypes of women leaders:
  • Passers: Those who blend in, making themselves palatable within the existing system.
  • Pushers: Those who directly challenge norms and seek structural change.
  • Peacekeepers: Those who prioritize harmony, mediating between the system and its disruptors.

The reality is that many of us have, at some point, played each of these roles. But in today's higher education climate—one of financial instability, shifting demographics, and ideological battles—passing and peacekeeping will not save us. If women in leadership are not actively exercising responsive agency, we are simply reinforcing a system that will, at best, tolerate our presence while rejecting our power.

The Fallacy of Fitting In

Let's be honest: Higher ed loves a woman leader who doesn't make too much noise. A woman who “fits.” A woman who absorbs the burden of change without demanding institutional accountability. But Landerholm makes it clear—fitting in is not enough. Responsive agency requires an intentional rejection of passive leadership. It calls for women to stop adapting to systems that were never meant to serve them and instead push those systems to serve everyone better.

This means challenging hiring and promotion practices that reward sameness over innovation. It means refusing to accept the narrative that women's leadership styles are a liability rather than an asset. It means resisting the urge to be grateful just to be in the room.

Determination Alone Won't Get Us There

We love the story of the determined woman leader who overcame every obstacle through sheer willpower. But let's be clear—determination alone is not a strategy. Personal resilience is not a substitute for structural change. Women in leadership cannot simply “outwork” bias. We cannot just “prove ourselves” into fair treatment. Responsive agency demands that we stop treating systemic problems as individual burdens and start leveraging our collective power to demand better.

Playing by the Rules Has Never Been a Winning Strategy

The unspoken expectation for women in higher ed leadership? Play the game, follow the rules, don't make people uncomfortable. But as Landerholm reminds us, playing by the rules is not enough. Because the rules were not written for our success—they were written to maintain the status quo.

If we are serious about advancing women's leadership in higher ed, we have to stop waiting for permission to lead differently. We have to take up space unapologetically, challenge inequitable practices openly, and mentor the next generation of women leaders not to fit in, but to build something better.

Responsive Agency as a Leadership Imperative

Landerholm's book is not just a reflection on the state of women's leadership in higher ed—it's a directive. Responsive agency is a call to action. It means rejecting passivity, embracing strategic resistance, and leveraging our positions to create lasting change. It means asking ourselves, every single day: Am I leading in a way that challenges this system, or am I simply surviving within it?

Women in higher education leadership do not have the luxury of neutrality. The choices we make—whether to push, pass, or keep the peace—don't just affect us. They shape the institutions we leave behind. The question is, what kind of legacy are we building?

Back to listing